3.5 stars
Incredible? No. Pretty good? Yes. Which puts me in the good company of 1,000 American newspaper and magazine headline writers who can't resists playing off the "incredible" in the title.
But first, R, my younger daughter, asked me what Tony Stark (Robert Downey Jr.) meant when he made a cameo appearance at the end of the film, when he told Gen. Ross (William Hurt) that he was "putting together a team" which might contain the Hulk. I explained to her that this meant Marvel was planning to make a movie version of the Avengers. As early baby boomers may recall, the Hulk was a member of the Avengers during the first two issues, then became a target of the group for some time afterwards. Stark funded the Avengers, and served as a member in his role as Iron Man.
This is a substantially better movie than the previous Hulk film; Edward Norton (Bruce Banner), Liv Tyler (Betty Ross) and Hurt (Gen. Ross), are just better casting than Eric Bana Jennifer Connelly and Sam Elliott. Zak Penn wrote a better script, and who knew that Louis Leterrier could, given this kind of material, be a better director than Ang Lee. In fact, it is a "reboot," (in the way that Batman Returns was a reboot of the Batman franchise), and this time the Hulk may have legs. Well, he always had legs, but you know what I mean...
This film concentrates on the essence of the Hulk--the conflicted nature of mild-mannered Banner, trying to control his Hulkiness. If there had been anger-management classes in the 60s, surely creators Stan Lee (who appears in a cameo as the gamma poisoning victim) and Jack Kirby would have sent Banner to one. As it is, Penn has to bring this archetypal cold war-based "hero" into the 21st century. Like most Marvel heroes (Spiderman: radioactive spider; Fantastic Four: Cosmic rays), Hulk is a victim of radioactivity--but you won't learn that from the film. So, like all Marvel heroes, Banner is flawed, human, tortured and beset with bad breaks and bad luck. This film shows us what that might be like. And it mixes in enough slam-bang action sequences to entertain the less cerebral viewer.
Norton is a genius, Tyler is a cipher, and Hurt is... well, his usual great self. I can't wait for the next one--because it might be even better.